Flogging a dead horse Print
Written by Jason Jones   
Friday, 06 June 2008

I wish we could stop flogging a dead horse. Sadly, the politicians won’t let us. They just keep insisting that subsidies and trade restrictions are good ideas. The Independent reports today that the Common Agriculture Policy (CAP) adds almost £900 each year to UK food bills. Much has and more could be written about how these subsidies hurt the average person in the EU. But, as Maxine Firth wrote:

CAP is one of the biggest iniquities facing farmers in Africa and other developing counties. They cannot export their products because they compete with the lower prices made possible by payments. In addition, European countries dump thousands of tons of subsidised exports in Africa every year so that local producers cannot even compete on a level playing field in their own land.


All of this is not to say the EU is the only culprit. Trade policies in Africa are prohibitively restrictive. However, the EU, UN, the US, and dozens of other countries, NGOs and IGOs try to solve Africa’s problems with foreign aid. Here’s a better idea: Let them produce and compete! Let free trade work. A couple of weeks ago, The Economist reported that 250m of the 270m people lifted from poverty since 1990 were Chinese. Is this because of foreign aid to China? Absolutely not! The Chinese government made capitalist reforms, and foreign nations opened up trade. Although China has a long way to go, it has come a long way and is now freer than it has ever been. Africa is different, but requires the same approach—internal and external changes to trade policy.

Perhaps an introductory course in economics would serve our politicians well.

Comments (2)Add Comment
...
written by Not an Economist, June 06, 2008
I find it odd that people argue that food subsidies increase production, presumably using the food mountains in Europe as evidence. The suggestion is that If farmers don't get the subsidy (be it a tariff or money ) then they wont produce food and so world output of food would decline

It sounds reasonable but to my mind it ignores the other side of the equation: the reduction in output of foreign farmers (e.g. the third world producers you refer to) who cannot export to Europe and so their output necessarily declines.
Doha!
written by Cityunslicker, June 06, 2008
Quite agree, yet the latest Doha round looks like failing too. I wrote more on it

Write comment
This content has been locked. You can no longer post any comment.

Powered by Azrul's Jom Comment for Joomla!
busy