Adam Smith Institute

Europe's favourite think tank website
  • Narrow screen resolution
  • Wide screen resolution
  • Decrease font size
  • Default font size
  • Increase font size
Power lunch with Andrew Mitchell MP Print E-mail
Written by Dr Eamonn Butler   
Thursday, 10 July 2008

Andrew Mitchell, Shadow Secretary of State for International Development, was our guest at a Power Lunch in Westminster this week.

Adam Smith wrote that nothing was necessary to lift a state from the deepest 'barbarism' to an advanced society, other than peace, 'easy taxes' and 'a tolerable administration of justice'. Mitchell too recognizes the importance of conflict resolution in providing the right soil on which economic achievement can grow. States in political and military turmoil don't create or export economic goods – rather,  they export terrorism and desperate migrants. That is why Conservatives are going to integrate foreign, development and security strategies with the creation of the National Security Council. Under this joined-up policy, DfID would be more than just an aid agency: it would be a partner in development, trade and security.

Quite right. Development isn't just about giving people money. The Conservatives also intend to set up an evaluation agency to make sure that UK taxpayers' money is spent effectively and transparently, rather than ending up in the pockets of politicians and officials.

And, thank goodness, they recognize that the engine of growth is trade and enterprise. I feel that they rather like what Peter Mandelson has been saying – that EU farm subsidies and trade restrictions keep people in poor countries impoverished – which is hardly good for traders in the richer countries either. But I think that even with the formidable Mandelson on side, getting the EU to sort out its spaghetti of trade barriers is a pretty tall order.

Comments (2)Add Comment
...
written by Dr Alister McFarquhar, July 10, 2008
Its hard to know how Tory policy will turn out in power. Currently it is camoflaged by desire to claim the perceived marginal ground

On Aid Tories need to learn the difficulty of delivery which reaches the Poor.

As PS says here [9 July] 2008

“The foreign aid situation is becoming increasingly farcical. As William Easterly, author of The White Man’s Burden put it: “The status quo — large international bureaucracies giving aid to large national government bureaucracies — is not getting money to the poor.” As Prof Easterly intimates, the failure stems from the insistence of OECD government donors to give the lion share of aid directly to governments, who they then rely on to plan, manage and deliver healthcare. “

You would think all Parties experience of NHS at home with diminishing or negative marginal returns to spending would suffice.

But then whats delivery got to do with it at home or abroad.? Politics seem to be driven by headline spending and fiddled targets and statistics.

More, I think the counterproductive effect of farm subsidies is a factoid. Substitution among temperate and tropical foods is limited- perhaps rice and maize. Export subsidies cannot be justified while farm prices are low in poor countries. But if production in poor countries fails to respond enough to high prices, farm subsidies at home may be the best way to feed the starving abroad via WFP.

The real damage to trade has been done by Carbon Control Policy by contributing to rocketing oil price and exhortation to dig up the lawn and minimise food miles.
...
written by Rosa Manson, July 16, 2008
Teff grain originally grown in Ethiopia, is for export only, but now that the Dutch and German governemtn have been given permission to grow Ethiopian Teff grain in Europe, why can't the surplus Teff grain be returned to Ethiopia. Surely thsi is one way of assisting the farmers who are dying of starvation, because of what they export.

Rosa Manson

Write comment
This content has been locked. You can no longer post any comment.

busy
 

About the ASI

The Adam Smith Institute is the UK's leading innovator of free-market economic and social policies. Politically independent and non-profit, the Institute promotes its ideas through reports, briefings, events, media appearances, and its website and blog. For further information, click here.

Join our email list

Keep up-to-date with the latest events, reports and information from the Adam Smith Institute by joining our fortnightly email list. It's free and you can unsubscribe at any point. Just enter your email address here: 


Support the ASI

Enter Amount: