Miscellaneous Wordsmith Miscellaneous Wordsmith

Silliest blog comment in the world...ever?

4728
silliest-blog-comment-in-the-worldever
i) As the production of goods and provision of services becomes less labour-intensive, economies need mechanisms to distribute goods and services to those no longer directly involved in production. At some point, state-mediated re-distribution of products and services grows. This leads to extended periods of education and retirement (to keep people out of the workforce), growing prison populations (to keep people out of the workforce), and the proliferation of law creation, law enforcement and law interpretation positions and professions. How will we provide income (a share of the economy) to the laid off police officers, prison guards, soldiers, bureaucrats, lawyers, judges, social workers, teachers, bankers, tax accountants etc. if we shrink government?

ii) In the cell biology analogy to an economy, only a small minority of genes and proteins are actually involved in metabolism (the equivalent of production of goods and services). Most genes and proteins (ca. 80%) are involved in monitoring the environment and regulating cellular activity. So, in a highly mechanized, capital intensive society, it is reasonable that most people are involved in monitoring or regulatory activities, rather than primary production.

Commenter on 'Stop' The Economist.

Read More
Miscellaneous Wordsmith Miscellaneous Wordsmith

Charles Murray on happiness

4711
charles-murray-on-happiness
Earlier, I said that the sources of deep satisfactions are the same for janitors as for CEOs, and I also said that people need to do important things with their lives. When the government takes the trouble out of being a spouse and parent, it doesn’t affect the sources of deep satisfaction for the CEO. Rather, it makes life difficult for the janitor. A man who is holding down a menial job and thereby supporting a wife and children is doing something authentically important with his life. He should take deep satisfaction from that, and be praised by his community for doing so. Think of all the phrases we used to have for it: “He is a man who pulls his own weight." “He’s a good provider." If that same man lives under a system that says that the children of the woman he sleeps with will be taken care of whether or not he contributes, then that status goes away. I am not describing some theoretical outcome. I am describing American neighborhoods where, once, working at a menial job to provide for his family made a man proud and gave him status in his community, and where now it doesn’t. I could give a half dozen other examples. Taking the trouble out of the stuff of life strips people—already has stripped people—of major ways in which human beings look back on their lives and say, “I made a difference."

Charles Murray 'The Europe Syndrome and the Challenge to American Exceptionalism'.

Read More
Miscellaneous Wordsmith Miscellaneous Wordsmith

A collectivist you might agree with

4703
a-collectivist-you-might-agree-with
Freedom, morality, and the human dignity of the individual consists precisely in this; that he does good not because he is forced to do so, but because he freely conceives it, wants it, and loves it.

Mikhail Bakunin

Read More
Miscellaneous Dr. Eamonn Butler Miscellaneous Dr. Eamonn Butler

Salt grit

4688
salt-grit

The demand for road salt has reached such heights that there are now police cordons around the salt mine yards to control the endless stream of lorry traffic, not to mention the punch-ups. Contractors are desperate to get road salt, but in many cases it is a forlorn hope – not because the market has somehow failed, but because the government is trying to control it.

It is the same pattern we have seen before. Any sign of a problem, and Downing Street butts in and says that it is stepping in. Not that it is doing a very good job of it. In their buyers' market, besieged by lorries, the salt producers tell me that they would rather like the government to tell them exactly who they should and should not serve. (And local authorities, punch drunk from public criticism, would probably rather like Gordon Brown to tell them which streets and pavements to grit and which not to – a task that should keep him busy for a while.)

What people don't realise, though, is that the government has already decided the priority customers. And the priority customer is – you guessed it, the government. Rock salt suppliers tell me that right from the start of the cold spell, they have been telling private contractors that they can only supply government users, like local councils, health authorities, and the military. So contractors I know of have been reduced to buying food-grade salt in 25kg bags to spread in their contract areas.

Not only that, the local authorities have been instructed to spread what salt they have very thinly. So the gritters are out every day (for which, of course, the government is happy to take credit), even though they are not doing much good. Council officers tell me that what you need to do is to put down plenty at the outset to prevent roads icing up, then renew it as needed.

About the only people who are content are the drivers of the gritting lorries, some of whom, I'm told, are netting £1000 a week thanks to – you guessed – public sector wage contracts. When authorities decide to do preventative gritting at the end of the day, well, that is after their scheduled hours, so it is double time. Or when they go out early it is double time (and it stays double time for as long as they are out). Then Saturdays and Sundays are double time again.

It all seems like an extremely expensive way of the government getting what it wants. But as a way of keeping the country moving – I would take that with a pinch of salt.

See Dr Butler's new Alternative Manifesto here.

Read More
Miscellaneous Wordsmith Miscellaneous Wordsmith

Labour Party finances

4689
labour-party-finances

Funny how the Labour Party's finances reflects the mess they have made of public finances::

We had – in every year bar one – spent more money than we had raised. Year on year our debts had soared to £30million.

Peter Watt 'Peter, we've spent 10 years working with Gordon and we don't like him. The more the public get to know, the less they will like him too' Daily Mail

Read More
Miscellaneous Dr. Eamonn Butler Miscellaneous Dr. Eamonn Butler

Panmure House

4679
panmure-house

The development and restoration of Panmure House – Adam Smith's home in Edinburgh – has been the subject of long drawn out discussions between the Edinburgh Business School (its new owners), Historic Scotland, and the Edinburgh City Council planners.

Everyone is keen that this historic house should be accessible to the public as a venue for public meetings, concerts, seminars and other events. But it is obvious that the building's footprint is not large enough to accommodate both the meeting rooms and the services (staircase, toilets, lifts, kitchens) that a modern venue requires. Edinburgh Business School's architect solved this problem by creating a glass atrium housing an external staircase. It is a brilliant solution. It provides the necessary access in a stylish way that does not violate the house, nor require some ghastly solid extension, and indeed which keeps the main elevation visible and allows it to be attractively lit.

Historic Scotland have objected to pretty much all proposals for an external stair. It would be a shame if Edinburgh's planning committee, which meets next week, takes its cue from them and rejects the proposal. Panmure House will survive only if it has a viable function. Without that, it becomes a useless hulk that nobody will care for, and which will decay. I am sure that Historic Scotland does not want that. And given the sorry state that past public-sector owners have left it in – the only remaining original feature is one fireplace in the attic – the Edinburgh Business School's sympathetic restoration plans are definitely a welcome improvement. Let's not allow Adam Smith's home to decay and be forgotten as it has been over the last half century.

Read More
Miscellaneous admin Miscellaneous admin

Merry Christmas to one and all

4628
merry-christmas-to-one-and-all
This is the time of year when for many of us thoughts turn to family and friends and home.  The team at the Adam Smith Institute wish all those who enjoy reading this site a merry Christmas.  To those journeying to be with family and friends we wish a safe trip, and to all we hope the festive season brings fulfillment and pleasure, and that the New Year ahead will bring the promise of opportunities and achievement.  Our thoughts and good wishes are with you.

 

Read More
Your subscription could not be saved. Please try again.
Your subscription has been successful.

Blogs by email